Thank you to narrator Sophie James for providing me with a free audiobook in return for this honest review.
I was really excited to read this book after reading the synopsis and finding it has a similar storyline to one of my favourite books ‘The Boy Who Sneaks In My Bedroom Window’. Two friends of different popularity status who share a special bond when the boy creeps into the girls bedroom at night to sleep in the same room together.
This story follows Lukas and Melinda, who are separated by ‘Lindy’s choice to leave town and not come back after a drunken encounter with Lucas that left her scarred. She then returns four years later to face her biggest challenge. Him.
The Good Stuff
I’m really sorry to say that I wasn’t so impressed by the story that I have many good points. The narrator, Sophie James is fantastic. Her voices for both characters were brilliant and really easy to differentiate.
I liked the idea of the mirror killer. It was a good story, I guessed who it was straight away but there was a little red herring.
It was also quite cute when Lucas and Lindy would have their moments together. I never actually got bored listening to the story.
I quite liked Lindy’s friend Tara, and wouldn’t mind reading the next book to find out about their story. I’d just be a little cautious due to my bad points…
Not My Cup Of Tea
This story is a feminist’s nightmare…I’m not a complete feminist…I do like a little damsel in distress story or an alpha male but this story really took the biscuit. At the beginning of the story, Lindy was overweight and unpopular. She left town, came back stick thin (because she skipped meals and didn’t eat…) and was suddenly socially acceptable.
People liked her, her all-time crush was obsessed with her, and all was fine and dandy. Bottom line moral of the story…if your crush doesn’t like you, lose all of your weight and you’re a winner.
The characters didn’t exactly win me over. Lindy was a whiny, needy character who really needed to stand up for herself and figure out how to make her own decisions.
Lucas was probably the worst character I’ve ever read. When he was around Lindy he was quite sweet, around other people however…the guy really needed to be punched. Personally, if I was Lindy, I’d have made a second thought about whether I wanted to be with Lucas the first time he spoke to his girlfriend. He talked with such disrespect that it was disgusting, whether she was annoying or not, there was no need to talk to people the way that Lucas did.
The characters in the story liked to make their adulthood known. However, this book has the most overbearing parents that I have ever read. The second that a choice needed to be made the parents were in and making choices for the characters, Our characters were also more than willing to bend over backward for them too. I’m respectful to everyone, especially my parents, but all I will say is that if my father tried to make decisions about who I would be living with he’d be told to take a long walk off a short pier.
Another thing about this book is that the dialogue didn’t flow. Some of it felt quite stiff and unnatural and at some points, even the narrator seemed to struggle to understand what characters were actually saying.
Overall Rating
I really wanted to like this story. It seemed so like many books that I love, but it just wasn’t. The characters made me angry and the story didn’t really seem to have much purpose. The narrator of the book is fantastic, I think if I weren’t listening to it, I’d have likely gotten bored with the story and given up reading. Sophie really did save it for me.
2 stars **
Sorry…