I’m sure everyone at some point in their life has been told by a book lover ‘Always Read the Book First!’ and has almost felt a little judged when they’ve mentioned that they’ve watched Twilight but never touched one one of Stephanie Myers‘ Books. I am guilty of this too! But has anyone ever noticed how offended book lovers actually get when they finally watch a film and it’s not completely on point with a book
If you follow me on Facebook you’ll know that I’ve been getting majorly excited as it’s been a very good month for some authors that I follow.
Firstly, Coleen Hoover, an author who I’ve only recently read a couple of books for, has announced that the first book of hers that I read – ‘Confess’ is being released as a series on Go90.com (Only in the US 😦 ) on the 4th April.
Also, one of my favourite authors Rebecca Donovan has just finished a fundraising campaign to turn my favourite books, the Breathing Series, into a series for the television screen!
This brings me to my point of this blog…Books VS Screen!
Some books have to be changed when being made visual, for different reasons. I will hold my hands up and say that I will often watch a film before I read the book, that way, I won’t be offended by all the cuts and changes that have been made. I’ll then be blown away when I do read the book.
One huge example of this would be J.K.Rowling’s ‘Harry Potter’. Mainly because if you haven’t heard of Harry Potter, you’ve likely been living under a rock. I will hold up my hands and say that I HAVE NEVER READ ALL OF THE HARRY POTTER SERIES…I know…blasphemy. But having a mother and partner who have completed the Harry Potter books numerous times I am aware of the many cuts and changes that have been made in the films due to them being mentioned every single time we watch a film:
Obviously, in this case, the Harry Potter books were HUGE. If a director had taken on every single scene in this series, the films would still be going on with a 27-year-old Harry.
Plus, with the highly established actors they had in each film, I’m guessing they were pretty comfortable letting them just do their own thing. Michael Gambon doesn’t need to keep calm…he’s Dumbledore.
The first book/film transformation that I was majorly disappointed about was The Duff by Kody Keplinger. I somehow go this book free on Amazon while The Duff film was being shown in the cinemas so I decided to read it before the film came out. Being a huge click flick fan I knew that I’d like the film regardless. I got absolutely hooked on this book and its storyline. It had a nice twist to the ‘unpopular girl likes popular boy, they end up together’ kind of theme. When I finished the book, the film was out on DVD and I couldn’t wait to watch it. I bought it, used food to bribe my boyfriend to sit and watch it with me, grabbed a blanket, switched off the lights and eagerly settled down to watch it.
I was mortified at what they did!!
Westley was a next door neighbour who knew Bianca from a young age,
Toby was an asshole,
some bitchy girl called Madison appeared out of nowhere
and
they swapped and alcoholic dad for a career driven mum.
I could understand why some bits were changed for this film. It was developed for a teen audience and in the book. If you haven’t read the book – Bianca and Westley begin as ‘popular’ and ‘unpopular’, with the mutual dislike that comes with it. They then become secret friends with benefits while Bianca chases her crush, Toby, who is actually a genuine and nice person and ends up dating Bianca but lets her go when he realises that she’s developed feelings for Westley. I could understand that that specific relationship was scratched out. When it was for a younger, impressionable audience it would have been slated if the FWB relationship was used. But did they really have to make them neighbours? And WHY WHY WHY did they ruin Toby??
One book that isn’t really changed by a film, however, is ‘The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas’ by John Boyne. I watched this film in school and loved it. Always having an interest in history like this. A friend of the family offered to lend me to the book a few years later and to be honest, I was a little apprehensive because I loved the film so much and didn’t want it to be ruined for me. It wasn’t at all. There were barely any differences in the book, other than the film had a little more dramatic effect. I was so relieved.
I can see why people always like to read the book first. I know after watching the Hunger Games, I wasn’t in much of a rush to read the book. But after one of my friends told me about some differences between book and film for that I am pretty tempted to read it at some point.
So, as I said, personally. I will often watch the films first if they are already out, mainly because I take an eternity to read and if it’s in the cinemas, it won’t be by the time I’ve finished.
I actually enjoy seeing the differences in books to films (like Savage Peten Pan beating the lost boys…pretty grim J.M.Barrie).
There are a number of books that I read which I’d love to see being made into a film, and I cannot wait to see the upcoming series’ when they are complete. I think the main reason I’m so excited is because I know and love the stories. I will now say that I much prefer reading the book first.